Abstract
This article provides a critical reflection on Shirli Gilbert's account of South African Jewish historiography, drawing from the author's personal experiences and academic background. The author, primarily a scholar of Polish and Jewish history, recounts their early engagement with South African history and Marxist ideology during their time at the University of the Witwatersrand. They discuss their involvement in leftist organizations and the influence of key figures like Jack Simons. The author highlights the need for more comprehensive research on Jewish involvement in South African leftist movements, particularly biographical studies of influential Jewish figures. Additionally, they emphasize the importance of further investigating the complex role of the Communist Party of South Africa in the struggle against apartheid and the subsequent evolution of South African communism, especially in light of recent geopolitical developments.